top of page

The Rise of Relatable Influencers

  • Writer: Zoe Frantz
    Zoe Frantz
  • Mar 31
  • 4 min read

Here’s the deal: the influencer world is shifting in a major way, and it’s time we talk about it. Macro-influencers might have been the go-to stars of the past, but today’s audiences are all about realness. People crave authenticity and connection, and brands that tap into those vibes are seeing incredible results.


That’s where micro-influencers and your loyal customers come in. They’re not just relatable; they’re total game-changers for building trust and driving engagement. So, if you’re ready to rethink your strategy and embrace this exciting new era, keep reading!


Why Macro-Influencers Are Losing Their Appeal

Macro-influencers, who have hundreds of thousands or even millions of followers, once defined the influencer marketing space. They brought massive reach, polished content, and the allure of celebrity status to brands aiming for wide visibility. However, times have shifted, and the once indisputable reign of macro-influencers is facing challenges.


The Problem with Perfection

Today’s audiences value authenticity over perfection. The curated, seemingly unattainable lifestyles often portrayed by macro-influencers can feel disconnected from everyday experiences. A designer-clad influencer vacationing on a yacht may capture attention, but it often lacks relatability for viewers navigating daily decisions, like which local café offers the best coffee deal.


High Costs, Low Engagement

Another growing concern is the cost of working with macro-influencers. Collaborations can cost thousands, or even millions, of dollars, and the return on investment doesn’t always justify the expense. Additionally, large follower counts don’t necessarily equate to high engagement. Audiences of macro-influencers can be vast but passive, lacking the deep connections that drive meaningful interaction with your brand.


The Shift Toward Authenticity

Modern consumers prioritize genuine interactions and trust over celebrity endorsements. This shift has opened the door for smaller, more relatable influencers and even loyal customers to emerge as effective and authentic advocates for brands.


The Power of Micro-Influencers

Micro-Influencers Offer Relatability & Authenticity

Micro-influencers, with follower counts ranging from 1,000 to 100,000, are rapidly becoming the preferred choice for brands looking to connect with audiences in a meaningful way. Their relatability and ability to foster authentic relationships set them apart in today’s marketing landscape.


Why Micro-Influencers Are Thriving

  1. Genuine Connections: Micro-influencers maintain closer relationships with their followers, who often see them as trusted friends rather than distant figures. This results in higher engagement rates and a stronger sense of trust in their recommendations.

  2. Cost-Effectiveness: Partnering with micro-influencers is not only budget-friendly but also allows brands to collaborate with multiple creators, amplifying their reach without breaking the bank.

  3. Niche Targeting: Many micro-influencers cater to specific interests or demographics, enabling brands to deliver highly targeted messages that resonate deeply with their ideal audience.


How to Work with Micro-Influencers

Collaborating with micro-influencers doesn’t have to be complex. Here are a few steps to get started:

  • Identify the Right Fit: Focus on influencers who align with your brand’s values and appeal to your target market.

  • Prioritize Engagement: A smaller but highly engaged audience often delivers better results than a large, disengaged one.

  • Build Partnerships: Treat micro-influencers as collaborators rather than contractors. Authentic relationships lead to campaigns that truly resonate.


Turning Loyal Customers into Influencers

One of the most innovative trends in influencer marketing is focusing on your existing customers. These individuals already know, love, and use your products, making their advocacy natural and credible.


Your Customers=The Ultimate Brand Advocates

Your customers’ enthusiasm for your products speaks volumes. They’re the ones leaving glowing reviews, sharing your products on social media, and recommending your brand to friends. This type of advocacy is not only authentic but also free of the transactional feel that traditional influencer partnerships can sometimes carry.


Brands Leading the Way

A red and white airplane flying over city buildings. A makeup palette is shown. Text: "Tarte has shifted its focus towards rewarding loyal customers."

Tarte Cosmetics has set a strong example in this space. While they previously relied exclusively on macro-influencers, Tarte has now shifted its focus toward rewarding loyal customers by gifting products and even organizing all-expenses-paid trips. These initiatives have sparked excitement and generated organic, buzzworthy content that feels genuine.


Other creative approaches include:

  • Surprise-and-Delight Campaigns: Sending unexpected gifts to loyal customers can inspire them to share their excitement online, spreading positive buzz for your brand.

  • Customer Spotlights: Featuring real customers in your marketing materials highlights their authentic experiences and builds trust.

  • Exclusive Perks: Rewarding your most engaged customers with early access to products or special discounts strengthens their loyalty and encourages them to share their enthusiasm with others.


Relatability is the Key to Success

It’s simple, consumers want to see themselves in your messaging, and showcasing micro-influencers or loyal customers using your products makes your brand feel accessible and trustworthy.


The ROI of Authenticity

Investing in relatable influencers and customer advocacy not only reduces costs but also delivers stronger engagement and loyalty. By fostering genuine connections, you’re building a community that supports your brand long-term.


Making the Shift

If your marketing efforts have relied heavily on macro-influencers, now is the time to pivot. Incorporating micro-influencers and customer-centric campaigns will not only modernize your strategy but also align your brand with the values your audience cares about most.


Building Connection Through Authenticity

The world of influencer marketing is evolving, and authenticity is taking center stage. While macro-influencers may still have their place, the rise of micro-influencers and loyal customer advocates offers a more relatable, cost-effective, and impactful approach to connecting with your audience. It’s time to reconsider your influencer marketing strategy to focus on authenticity and connecting with the consumer.


bottom of page